For a long time I worked with the module sounds of my Roland TD-30. They are really good, only the toms and the cymbals never convinced me. That's why I bought plugins for my Macbook. I'll list some pros and cons of e-drum modules and plugins here. I also show you my favorites.
E-drum modules and plugins are both valuable tools for drummers who play electronically. Both have their own advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between the two depends primarily on the drummer's personal preferences and requirements.
An e-drum module is a separate device that connects to the e-drumset and produces the sounds and tones. It usually has a variety of preloaded sounds suitable for different genres of music, as well as a way to import or create your own sounds.
Some of the advantages of e-drum modules are:
Ease of use: E-drum modules are usually very intuitive to use and do not require in-depth knowledge of music production or computer use.
Portability: E-Drum modules can be easily transported from one place to another, making them ideal for musicians who are often on the go.
Real drum feel: e-drum modules allow you to control and change the sound directly on the set, offering a more realistic playing experience for many musicians.
Pre-prepared sounds and tones
Ability to import or create your own sounds
Disadvantages of e-drum modules:
limited customizability
limited sound variety
higher price compared to plugins
dependence on the quality of the module
limitations in extensibility
Plugins are software instruments that run on a computer and create the sounds and tones. They usually offer greater flexibility and customizability than e-drum modules, as they usually offer many more sounds and sound options.
Some of the advantages of plugins are:
Infinite variety of sounds: Plugins usually offer an infinite variety of sounds and tones suitable for almost any style of music.
Customizability: Plugins can be easily customized to the musician's individual needs by changing the sound parameters or adding your own samples.
Extensibility: plugins can be easily extended by buying more available or creating your own.
possibility to add own sounds
greater flexibility
However, plugins also have disadvantages, such as:
Requires computer knowledge: To use plug-ins effectively, it is necessary to be familiar with the computer's software and operating system.
Dependence on computer performance: sound quality can be affected by computer performance, which can cause delays or crashes.
Cost: Plugins can be expensive and purchasing multiple plugins can quickly become a large investment.
Overall, both e-drum modules and plugins offer their own advantages and disadvantages. E-drum modules are easier to use, more portable, and allow for a more realistic playing experience, while plugins offer endless sonic variety, customizability, and expandability.
My favorites for e-drum plugins
I personally own EZ Drummer 2 (EZD2) and Superior Drummer 3 (SD3).
Both plugins have their respective advantages and disadvantages. Therefore, I use the software as follows:
EZD2 for practice purposes, i.e. when I practice at home on the e-drumset, I use the EZD2 sounds. You can get good sounds very quickly.
I use SD3 for productions together with Logic Pro. The sound possibilities with SD3 are endless. But you also need patience and the leisure to get involved with the extensive software.
Conclusion
For musicians who prefer a simple and portable setup and don't have in-depth knowledge of music production or computer use, an e-drum module may be a better choice.
For musicians who need more flexibility and customizability and are willing to invest in software and computer skills, a plugin may be a better choice. Ultimately, the choice between the two options depends on the musician's personal preferences and requirements.
Comments